Episode 12 "Maybe This Time"

On Day 31, Whit and Ashlynn competed in a duel, with Whit being the victor, making Ashlynn the 5th member of the Jury. On Day 32, Nick and Justin begun fighting and arguing and both wanted each other out, when Macie won immunity, both campaigned to get the other out. At Tribal Council, Jeff couldn't ask any questions because Nick and Justin were too busy arguing. In the end, Justin was voted out 4-2, sending him to Redemption Island.